Investigation Report

Location: Foster's Hotel, Chama, New Mexico
Date: 12, 13 February, 2005
Personnel Participating: Teams 1 and 2, Cody and Bob
Weather Conditions: Snow
Humidity: 84%
Geomagnetic Storm Activity: Normal, no storms
Temperature: 35
Number of Photos taken: 203
Number with possible targets: 2
Average EM Readings: 6 mg
Average M fields Readings: 4 nt
Average E Field Readings: 2 vpm
Cold Spots detected: None
Hot Spots Detected: None
Olfactory Phenomena: Perfume
Visual Phenomena: None
Type of Investigation:
Investigation

Copyright 2005 by Cody Polston, Bob Carter and SGHA. All Rights Reserved.

Location Description and History

In the early 1800's the town of Chama was not only exciting but down right dangerous. As the youngest of the Tierra Amarilla Land Grant's historic villages, Chama was established at a time in New Mexico's history when much of northwestern New Mexico was without effective law enforcement.'


Outlaws and other disreputable types, along with businessmen and hard working settlers, were drawn to frontier towns like Chama which sprang up along the path of the railroad, in this case the Denver and Rio Grande.


One of the earliest descriptions of Chama appeared within weeks after the railroad reached the site which was to become the new town. A March 9, 1881, article in the Santa Fe Daily New Mexican reported the little town of Chama was "Fast growing a reputation for lawlessness". Holdups, murders and shootings were so frequent that few people paid any attention to them.

It was this kind of lawlessness which in another newspaper story earned this fledgling railroad settlement the label of "The Hurrah town at the front of the Narrow Gauge". The term "Hurrah" in territorial New Mexico was not intended as a compliment. Foster's hotel was in existence at this time.
By the middle of March, however, a group of Chama's more respectable citizens, fed up with matters formed a vigilante committee. Members paraded around the town with a prominently displayed rope and explained to all the "bunko steerers, thieves and murderers" that they had two hours to leave. Apparently they were quite persuasive, for most of the original element "left gratefully", at least temporarily.
Another reporter who visited Chama later that same month observed that although the roughest criminal element had left, many other undesirables remained. Large numbers of "soiled doves" and "tin horn" gamblers, were making themselves quite obnoxious, but fortunately, were generally too tame to be considered dangerous.

At that time Chama was still a typical railroad town consisting largely of tents. With the exception of a few railroad offices and some commercial businesses, one being Foster's Hotel Bar and restaurant, every tent and building was utilized as a saloon or dance hall where the gamblers and "soiled doves" plied their Trade.

As the town grew, other and more dangerous elements made their appearance, not only at Chama, but at other towns further along the railroad such as Bloomfield and Durango. Gangs led by desperadoes such as Ike Stockton, Charlie Allison and other hardened refugees of the Colfax County Wars in northwest New Mexico, vied for control, not only of the towns, but for the entire northwest region of New Mexico.

The situation deteriorated so badly that Governor Lew Wallace was forced to send Adjutant General Max Frost to Rio Arriba in early April 1881 to investigate. Frost's report described Chama as "very lawless and disorderly" and concluded that the average citizen risked his life simply by walking the streets in broad daylight. General Frost also reported that the situation was aggravated by a lack of local law enforcement. Chama itself had no constable, and very recently a person appointed as deputy sheriff had been involved in the shooting of two railroad employees and had nearly been lynched.

One tongue in cheek report indicated Chama had no mosquitoes, but that the bullets which passed through the tents at night served the purpose of keeping residents from sleeping as well as those little pests. The writer also suggested that if anyone who was tired of life and had scruples about committing suicide, he could go to Chama and easily find someone quite willing to do the job for him.

In the meantime, excitement remained the order of the day in Chama. It was reported that every man who dared walk the street in Chama had to be armed and some were described as "walking arsenals". The report added that most of the population "spend their time at night".. in rioting, gambling. Drinking, loafing and seem to take a special delight in firing off six shooters and Winchester rifles.

Foster's Hotel was a known saloon, dance hall and brothel during its past. The building has undergone several changes over the years, the most notable in the 1920's when a second wing was added on. This second section is what houses the current hotel. The second floor of the original building is closed to the public due to safety concerns. The wall paper and several pieces of furniture date back to its "old west" days.

This article was prepared from material found in several of New Mexico's historic newspapers. Much of the information however, comes directly from original documents found in the collections of the New Mexico State Records Center and Archives in Santa Fe and was written by Robert Torrez (Local Historian).

Reported Phenomena

The room where a female judge was poisoned.

The closed off second story of the old hotel contains three areas that are believed to be haunted. The first is located on the southwest corner of the building.

In the late 1800's a woman was elected as the local judge. However, several men of the town did not like the idea of a woman becoming a judge. They resolved the situation by sneaking into her hotel room and adding poison to a pitcher of water. She was found dead in the morning.

It has been reported that the sound of a woman choking and gasping for breath can be heard in the empty room. This is often accompanied by a cold spots or a cold "gust of wind" in the room.

Across the hall is yet another room that has a ghostly inhabitant that has refused to check out. Staff at the hotel believe that it is the ghost of a small girl who died of an illness there over a hundred years ago. The sound of her crying an calls can be heard from the room, often having the late night staff in the bar below suspecting that children have broken into the building. A quick search of the second floor reveals that the building is secure and no one is present in the area. No one alive at least.

The third room of the old section of the hotel that has a haunted reputation is located a few rooms back on the south side. Rumor has it that this room is haunted by the ghost of a cowboy from the town's railroad days. He is unidentified but his footsteps are often heard walking around on the second floor by the late night staff working on the floor below.

The newer section of the hotel has its share of hauntings as well. A previous tenant of room 21 was insistent that someone had a key to his room. He would often see a dark figure moving about his room, often as the figure was walking towards the door. The figure would mysteriously disappear when the tenant investigated further.

People staying in Room 25 often report Hot and Cold spots. The areas of heat and cold are extremely concentrated and move swiftly about the room for several minutes.

Room that is haunted by the ghost of a small girl.

The Investigation

Due to the size of the hotel and time limitations, Teams 1 and 2 were tasked to investigate both wings of the hotel in the same night. Team 2 was assigned the task of investigating the old closed off section of the original building while Team 1 looked into the reports of ghostly activity in the addition built in the 1920's. The investigation was started at 9:00pm.

Entrance to the closed off section of the hotel.

Access to the closed off section of the old hotel is by a "out of place" corridor that is located half way up the main staircase leading to the wing of the hotel that is currently used. After climbing a few steps, the corridor turns to reveal a padlocked door, the only entrance to the abandoned section of the historic hotel. In this area we sat up our base area in order to control access to the investigation site and to stay out of sight from curious onlookers patronizing the hotel's bar. Both Teams assisted in setting up the DVR system and infrared cameras. The camera positions were determined by the amount of reported activity and their frequency. Cameras were placed in the poison room and the room haunted by the small girl. Cameras were also positioned on each side of the main hallway.

Team 2 began their investigation by doing sweeps for unusual DC electromagnetic fields on the second floor. Several readings were taken of fluctuating fields in the "poison room" and adjoining areas. Often a perfume like smell accompanied the appearance of the DC fields. These areas were determined to be the most active after searching the remainder of the area.

Meanwhile Team 1 searched the other wing of the hotel which is still in use. EM sweeps of Rooms 21 and 25 revealed that both areas were subject to high AC electromagnetic fields from old wiring. Room 25 also had high AC fields that were generated by a powerline coming into the building at that location. The readings from these areas are within the ranges known to cause hallucinogenic effects to electrically sensitive people. No significant DC fields were located in this section of the building. Afterwards the basement was searched with no significant findings.

At 11:00pm, a short break was taken by both teams as the Team captains discussed their findings. Two investigators were left at base to monitor the cameras. It was determined that both teams should focus on the older section of the building since the search of the newer wing turned up negative results. Several experiments were also discussed to see what effect they might have.

The investigation resumed at 11:30pm. Both teams went through the site taking EM readings and photographs. We then implemented the experiments we discussed during the break. The experiments situated around putting investigators in each of the "haunted" areas, in full view of the IR cameras, to see if any of the investigators would perceive similar experiences as the witnesses. Three different experiments were performed with different investigators in each location. Two of the experiments are noteworthy due to perceived phenomena coupled with unusual activity on the Infrared cameras.

Video

(Click on thumbnail to view the video)

Event 1 (Manually Operated IR Camera Approx. 10:30pm)

Although there is some dust contamination in this clip, one object moves upwards and seems to duck back down to move under the top of the door. The video was taken in the "poison room".

Event 2 (Camera Three 12:59am)

Camera 3 records an unusual light that arcs behind a investigator stationed in the small girl's room. This occurs seconds before the investigator hears noises resembling "breathing sounds and human voices". The light appears to move from behind the investigator and is temporarily obscured by her arm as it arcs downwards.

Event 3 (Camera One 1:06am)

An possible "orb" moves across the Poison room and fly upwards and out of the door. This may be a particle of dust, but its movement makes it interesting.

Event 4 (Camera One 2:47am)

Camera 1 picks up an unusual object that moves across the screen towards the left. The object then reverses direction and swoops downwards, disappearing into the floor. This occurs ninety seconds before the investigator in the doorway hears a noise that resembles "a gasping breath".

Photographs

(Click on the thumbnail to view the larger image)

Team 1 in Room 25

Stephanie

Carrie and Ashley

Hallway in the new wing

Team 1 in Room 21

Dust in the basement

The "Cowboy" Room

"Base"

Hallway of the old hotel

The "Poison Room"

The "small girl's room"

Unusual Photo

Exterior of the hotel

Hallway of new wing

Vince measuring EMF

Vince and Josh

Da Hitman

Vince, Carrie, Cody

Cody measuring AC fields

Detecting a power line

Another room in the old section of the hotel

Team 1 and Hitman searching the new wing

Unusual object near the top center of photo

Kat taking photos in the hall of the old hotel

Photo coupling in the small girl's room

 

Initial Conclusions

Last frame of the entire object before it vanishes

Event Four captured by camera one at 2:47am presents a interesting mystery. The object in the video changes direction multiple times and then appears to vanish into the floor. If this object was dust or an insect, it would continue to be visible to the camera until it leaves its point of view and disappears out of frame.

The camera itself is surrounded by Infrared emitters, which provides more than enough illumination to to keep objects visible while in the camera's viewing range. The object here does not do this. Enhanced frame by frame analysis clearly shows that the object disappears as it nears the bottom third of the camera's picture. The faint glow of the object mends into the floor as it appears to vanish into the floor itself. Foreign particles reflecting the IR light from the camera can not do this. This factor, combined with the sudden changing of directions, is highly suggestive that the object captured in this video is not dust, an insect, or other small particle moving in front of the camera's lens. Attempts to replicate this event were unsuccessful, the result being that any object near the lens stays visible until it leaves the frame completely.

The next thing that is interesting about Event 4 is that 30 seconds after the object moves through the picture, an investigator seated just outside of the doorway experienced a sound that resembled a woman gasping for breath. This time differential is consistent with Persinger's theories on EM Transduction and the time delays involved in experiencing the perceived phenomena. The "gasping for breath" sound experienced by the investigator is one of the experiences reported by many others in this particular room. As a result, this event is consistent with several of our hypotheses on how ghostly phenomena is perceived and offers some speculative data to those particular hypotheses.

Event 2 is just as curious. The video shows a small bright light that emerges from the investigator's left shoulder and arcs downwards. The light is obscured by the investigator's arm during this movement. A reflection of light from the camera's IR emitters can be ruled out due to the obstruction during its movement. The light is also in the room itself any there are not any other potential light sources that can sufficiently explain what the camera captures. In fact, the light itself casts its own reflection on the wall during the last visible part of its movement.

Camera 4 does show a moving light from a cameraman moving down the hallway but this is occurring in a section of the hotel separated from camera 3 by several walls, effectively ruling out any light reflections from that source.

As with Event 4, Event 2 is followed by the perceived sound of choking and faint voices. The investigator reacts within 10 seconds of the light appearing near her.

Photo Analysis

Two photographs taken during the investigation are also very interesting.

The first (above left) was taken down the hallway, looking towards the poison and small girl's rooms. It shows a mist like object that clearly casts a shadow behind it. The "orbs" in this photo have been determined to be dust particles. Photographs taken before and after this picture show nothing of interest in the hallway.

The second photograph was taken from the same location during Team two's initial sweep of the area. The object in the upper left middle section of the image shows an object that does not exhibit features that are typical of dust or other foreign objects moving in front of the camera's lens.

Photo and video analysis performed by Cindy Madrid, optics technician, a independent professional not affiliated with SGHA.

 

Back to Haunted New Mexico

Back to SGHA Home