Investigation Report

Location: Boothill Cemetery, Tombstone, AZ
Date: 12 March 2005
Weather Conditions: Partly cloudy, recent showers
Humidity: 65%
Geomagnetic Storm Activity: Inactive
Temperature: 62
Number of Photos taken: 219
Number with possible targets: 4
Average EM Readings: 5 mg
Average M fields Readings: 1 nt
Average E Field Readings: 1 vpm
Cold Spots detected: None
Hot Spots Detected: None
Olfactory Phenomena: None
Visual Phenomena: None
Type of Investigation: Ghost Hunt

All original information and photos Copyright 2005 by Cody Polston, Bob Carter and SGHA. All Rights Reserved.

Location Description and History

The early years of Tombstone's Boot Hill Graveyard (1879-1884) was originally called the "City Cemetery" After the city built the Tombstone Cemetery on the west end of Allen Street, the "City Cemetery" was then called the old cemetery. Sometime around 1929 and the towns first Helldorado Days, people started calling the "Old Cemetery" Boot Hill Graveyard.

The name was given to the frontier cemetery because most of it's early occupants died with their boots on. The name has had an appeal as part of the romantic side of the west and has become familiar as representing the violent end of a reckless life. But to the westerner, Boot Hill was just a graveyard where there "wasn't nobody there to let em' down easy with their hats off." Like the old saying, "There ain't many tears shed at a Boot Hill Buryin', and it is full of fellers that pulled their triggers before aimin'.

Many famous Tombstone folks lie there including the victims of the 1881 Shoot-out between the Earps and the Cowboys.

For many years, it was neglected. The desert overtook parts of it and vandals removed grave markers. Then, in the 1940's concerned citizens began the process of cleaning up the Old Cemetery and researching the placement of the graves to preserve it for future generations.

The cemetery is a shadow of its former self. It used to extend down the hill to the approximate location of the Circle K convenience store. On its west flank, graves were relocated when the present highway was constructed.

At the bottom of the hill is the Jewish cemetery. It once had a wall enclosing it that so high that a rider on horseback could not see over it. Today the wall is only about a foot tall. Many of the residents of this historic cemetery met violent deaths and even more are unidentified.

News Writer's Elegy in Boot Hill Cemetery, Tombstone Epitaph, April 4, 1928

By H. S. Hunter

That rocky slope under whose mounds lie the bones of pioneer gun fighters who drew unwisely and not fast enough is to undergo a little retouching. It may be no more desirable than possible to whitewash the picturesque sins of some of the buried on Boot Hill. Haloes and white robes would rest incongruously upon those wide-hatted gentlemen of the flaring mustachios, the fierce eyes and the nervous trigger fingers. But at least the stones that cover them can be whitened. There they are--mound after mound row--the graves of old Tombstone's unknown. Roughly oblong heaps of earth and rocks, scores of them, 150, or 200, or even more of them. On a few, wild thorny shrubs have taken root. Stones litter all. Rocks are banked on the graves. Even the earth is flinty. rough, hard, grim, forbidding is Boot Hill graveyard wherein lie the men who died with their boots on. Not a headboard, not a nameplate, nothing to identify any grave on all Boot Hill. Heavens above, could anything be more horribly symbolic? Here they lie, the bones of the gunman, the stage robbers, the cattle rustlers, the gamblers, painted Jezebels of the "cribs" and the dancehalls. Yes, and among the lot may not lie a few others, people who died forlorn and friendless but were decent and self-respecting. The innocent suffer with the sinful with whom they are linked in life. In death also, at least on Boot Hill. Not a blade of grass in this Boot Hill graveyard. Not a flower nor a tree, nor anything soft, lovely and tender. Nothing but the barren ground rocks, thorny shrubs. Everything hard, flinty, drab, Hard ugly, sinister like the lives of most of those whose bones lie under these stony mounds that almost touch so close are they. There is a saddening appropriateness about it. All those lively, vigorous, brave reckless, hard-hitting, hard-living, hard hating men and women who helped put color and life in the Tombstone of the early 80s have come to this. Nameless skeletons, side by side, row on row, on a stony, desolate hill.

"Live hard and dangerously" said Nietzsche, the German philosopher. These people did, and see what came of it.

Here are the "self-expressionist" of early Tombstone. Here is the "live-your-own-life crowd.

Here is the jazz gang of the 80s who lived by their wits, or their six-shooters or their sex appeal. Here are the men of hot heads and soft hands, who would rather shoot it out than work it out or reason it out.

Here are the boys who would rather take it from the other fellow by force then earn it. Here is the saloon gang and here are the dancehall habitués. Men and women who lived gaudy lives and were snuffed out.

Nameless. More Dust and bones. H.S. Hunter, El Paso Herald Reporter

Fifty years ago, Frank Vaughn, who has been a resident of Tombstone at intervals since that time and is again residing here, painted a wooden marker for the plot in Boot Hill cemetery where are buried McLowery and the Clanton brothers. The marker long since crumbled under the rays of the Arizona sun and a cross has been identifying the place during recent years. Now, under the plans of the Chamber of Commerce for improvements at Boot Hill, Mr. Vaughn is to reproduce the marker in form and wording. Other changes are to include a marker of wood for the five Bisbee murderers hanged under the law by Sheriff ward and a clearing of a driveway around the outer edge of the plot outside of the Escapule fence. Tombstone Epitaph, April 6, 1933

During the week, Dewey Chadwick, who has been in charge of a crew of workmen engaged in clearing and cleaning Boot Hill graveyard, counted the graves and found there are 259 outside of the drift fence, besides seventeen excavations from which bodies have been removed. This is more than were supposed to be in the old burying ground. There may be seen here a small grave marked by a tumbled-down stone bearing the name "Sam Harris." This is the only remaining grave in what was once the Jewish section of the cemetery, originally surrounded by an adobe wall. The wall long since disappeared without right or authority and the bodies all have been removed to other resting places with this one exception. On Monday, Harry Hughes, at work here, dug up a monkey wrench of antique design. It gives every evidence of having been buried beside one of the graves for approximately fifty years. It has been added to the collection of curios in the Chamber of Commerce Offices.Tombstone Epitaph, April 18, 1933

Reported Phenomena

Over the years several unusual photographs have been taken inside the cemetery by locals and tourists. Some people believe that ghosts are spirits of people that died unexpectedly, violently, and/or at the hands of others, gunfights, hangings, etc.

The Investigation

We arrived at sunset with the graveyard's present owner to conduct a ghost hunt of the property to include the Jewish cemetery, which she said no one has ever done. One Team circled the cemetery in a counter clockwise motion and down to the Jewish cemetery while the other Team moved clockwise. The Teams would eventually meet up at the starting point near the cemetery's entrance.

Team 1 moved south around by the graves of the Clanton's before moving north and back up towards the starting point. Several fluctuating EM fields were located, the most notable being near the north end of the cemetery. They gathered EVP samples at a random area just before finishing their search.

Team 2 located two several unusual temperature variations around graves at the north end of the graveyard. As investigators moved in to gather EM fields the temperature returned to normal. EM fields acquired by the team during their sweep averaged 5 mg.

     

Electronic Voice Phenomena (EVP)

Question
Possible Answer
Frequency
Listen
1. What is your name?
Hard to make out
312 HZ
2. How did you get in this place?
Sounds like "You'll never get me alive"
122.21 HZ
3. What do you prefer, Winchester or Shofield?
Sounds like "You dumby"
163.75 HZ

 

Initial Conclusions

Photographic Analysis

Photo 1

Photo 2

Photo 3

Photo 4

Despite recent light showers in the area, dust is a major problem when it comes to taking photographs after dark. The majority of the objects in our photographs are probably nothing more than dust or other airborne particles illuminated by the camera's flash. However, two photographs may have partially obscured"orbs" but there is not enough detail in either image to prove the object s were obscured

Photographs 1 and 2 have unusual clouds or mists in them. Initially we assumed that these were caused by dust clouds that were kicked up by the Investigators as they walked through the cemetery. The cemetery grounds are covered by gravel and if disturbed they are capable of producing such visual effects. However attempts to replicate this showed a "cloud" that looks completely different than those in these two photographs. The camera used to take these photographs was working properly and there is no reason to suspect a camera malfunction as the cause of the anomalies. We also examined the possibility of light reflections but were not able to ascertain a source for this to occur.

Photograph 4 has an unusual blurring in the left of the photo. The photos taken before and after this photograph show nothing unusual in them. No explanation as to how this blurring could occur in just a single photograph has not been explained.

Electromagnetic Field Analysis

A powerline crosses over the Jewish section of the cemetery. As you approach this section, AC EMF meters will register a small reading but it will vanish once you enter the Jewish section. This is due to the nature of the field generated by the powerline itself. The line is well shielded but this could easily throw off someone with less experience with the use of AC EMF meters.

The DC electromagnetic fields were mid-scale spikes that occurred in the northern section of the cemetery. No reasonable explanation was found for these fields.

EVP Analysis

Two of the samples obtained in the graveyard are quite clear and understandable. Sample 1 was recorded by a tombstone that stated that the person buried there was hung unjustly. Therefore the recorded answer is consistent with the question.

Sample 4 is also interesting because it suggests interaction with the investigators. The question that was first asked was "What do you prefer, Winchester or Colt?" After the interviewer was informed that Colt firearms had not been introduced yet, he asked the question again with the correct brand of firearm.

Sample 2 (What is your name?) is difficult to understand. The list of the known burials is listed below although there are also a large number of "unknown" graves throughout the cemetery.

Known residents buried in the cemetery

William Alexander 1880 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (killed by a premature blast while prospecting)

George Warren Atkins 1888 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (miner)

Jonathon Barton 1881 Boothill, Tombstone AZ

John Beather 1881 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (hanged)

Albert Bennett 1883 Boothill, Tombstone (Teamsters Bennett and Scott were ambushed by
Indians)

W.C. Bennett 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (heart trouble, native of England)

Eliz. Billings 1886 Boothill, Tombstone AZ

Frank Bowles 1880 Boothill, Tombstone AZ -

Steve Brammer 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ

Ernest Brodines 1882 Boothill, Tombstone (murdered) A miner, native of Germany

Mrs. R.L. Brown 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (natural death)

Pat Byrne 1882 Boothill, Tombstone Arizona (pneumonia)

Mrs. R.B. Campbell 1882 Boothill, Tombstone, AZ (suspect poisoning)

Malcolm Campbell 1882 Boothill, Tombstone, AZ (pneumonia)

Alfred Cantrell 1881 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (murdered by a
man named Brown who was later hanged for his crime.

William Carpenter 1881 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (Nephritis, Baptist minister in Tombstone)

David Cassidine 1879 Boothill, Tombstone - (killed)

Bronco Charlie 1880's Boothill, Tombstone AZ (shot by Ormsby, real name unknown)

Ah Chum aka "China Mary" 1906 Boothill, Tombstone, Arizona (Chinese merchant and brothel owner)

Billy Clanton Oct. 26, 1881 (19) Boothill, Tombstone, Arizona (murdered behind the OK Corral)

Newman Haynes Clanton August 13, 1881 Boothill, Tombstone, Arizona "Known as "Old Man" Clanton

Simon Constantine 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (killed with Thos.Kerney during a blast)

H.B. Cook 1882 Boothill, Tombstone, AZ

Thos. Cowan 1881 Boothill, Tombstone (Diphtheria, 11 months old)

Mrs. Clum 1880 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (John Clums wife)

Billy Clairborne Nov. 15, 1882 (22) Boothill, Tombstone, Arizona (shot by Leslie)

Peter Crawley 1881 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (killed)

Hans Christianson 1891 Boothill, Tombstone AZ

Christina B. Christianson 1892 Boothill, Tombstone AZ

Harry Curry 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (killed with Seymour Dye while hauling hay)

Lewis H. Daves "Lew" 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (cause of death Unknown, age 25, Tombstone attorney and
miner said to have built Tombstone's first adobe building on fourth Street, which served as a barber shop.

Bill Delaney Mar. 8, 1884 Boothill, Tombstone - legally hanged

A. Deloach 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ

Deron 1880's Boothill, Tombstone AZ (full name unknown, Shot by Slaughter while resisting arrest for his
Part in a train robbery)

May Doody 1881 Boothill, Tombstone (Diphtheria)

Dan Dowd Mar. 8, 1884 Boothill, Tombstone - legally hanged

Minnie Dowe 1881 Boothill, Tombstone, AZ

Jack Dunlap 1880's Boothill, Tombstone AZ (shot by Jeff Milton during an attempted train robbery. Lived long
enough to squeal on his friends who left him to die. Aka 3-Fingered Jack

Seymour Dye 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (shot by Indians with Harry Curry, while driving a hay wagon)

Dutch Annie 1883 Boothill, Tombstone (Brothel madam)

Thos. Fitzhugh 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (found dead in a water closet in the back of Mrs. Kings lodging house on Toughnut Street, where he roomed.

Judah Florentine Mar. 22, 1882 Boothill, Tombstone - aka Florentino Cruz & Indian Charlie, murdered by Wyatt Earp

George Fryer 1881 Boothill, Tombstone AZ

Freddie Fuss 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (small boy who drank stagnant or poison mine water)

J.J. Gardner Jan. 11, 1882 Boothill, Tombstone - shot in railroad camp on babacomari and died in Tombstone at age 42. Wagon master, born in Ohio

John Gibbons 1881 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (wagon accident crushed his skull)

John Gibson 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ ("he climbed the Golden stairs on the fumes from a pan of Charcoal" Malvina Lopez

John Alexander Gillespie March 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (was Cochise County Sheriff less than twelve hours when killed at Chandler Milk Ranch trying to arrest Billy Grounds and Zwing Hunt, suspected killers of Martin Peel. He died instantly when Hunt shot him in the head.

Verone Gray 1880's Boothill, Tombstone (suicide)

William Grounds "Billy" 1882 Boothill, Tombstone (shot in the face with a shot gun, by an officer questioning him about the Martin Peel murder)

Thomas C. Gregory 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ ( owned Tombstone's Gregory's Restaurant at 410 Fremont, born in England

Gregory 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ son of Thos. Gregory who died of meningitis Halderman Bros. Nov. 16, 1900 Boothill, Tombstone - (hanged)

Louis Hancock 1879 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (shot by John Ringo in bar room brawl in stafford Arizona, the fight allegedly started over a disparaging remark about a lady)

Frank Hart 1882 Boothill, Tombstone (shot with Jackson and Serroux over a mining claim)

John Heath Feb. 22, 1884 Boothill, Tombstone - lynched by Bisbee mob

Charles Helm 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ horse rancher on Ranch in the dragoon mountains, 34 years old
(shot by Wm. McCauley)

James patrick Hickey sept 1881 Boothill, Tombstone - first resident listed on stowe street in Charleston, allegedly shot by Wm. Clairborne in Charleston

John Hick 1878 Boothill, Tombstone, Arizona - (killed by Jeremiah McCormick at Watervale july 6, 1878 following a card game argument with William Quinn. Buried in the only white shirt found in Tombstone, belonging to Dr. D. S. Chamberlain, a visitor. Lucky Cuss Mine manager

Hilly Hickson 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (school boy died of injuries after falling off a pair of stilts)

Tex Howard Mar. 8, 1884 Boothill, Tombstone - legally hanged

J.W. Houten 1878 Boothill, Tombstone - aka Van Houten (killed by unknown assailants at Brunckow Mine, November 1878. Frank Stilwell and James Cassidy were arrested but acquitted. Allegedly beaten to death over a disputed mining claim.

Quong Gee Kee "Wan" Jan. 1938 Boothill, Tombstone Arizona. Can Can Restaurant owner

Thos. Kearny 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (killed with Simon Constantine during a blast)

Dan Kelley Mar. 8, 1884 Boothill, Tombstone - legally hanged

Miles E. Kellogg 1882 Boothill, Tombstone, AZ (natural death) Saloon keeper, age 44

Kansas Kid 1880's Boothill, Tombstone AZ (killed in a stampede, cowboy's real name unknown)

Mike Killeen June 22, 1880 (32) Boothill, Tombstone Arizona (Killed by Frank Leslie over a disagreement about Killeen's wife, Leslie married his widow)

 

Bill King 1880's Boothill, Tombstone AZ (shot by Burt Alvord, aka Cowboy Bill King. saloon keeper)

Jack King 1880's Boothill, Tombstone AZ (shot by Cherokee Hall)

John King 1881 Boothill, Tombstone (suicide by strychinine)

Billy Kinsman 1883 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (shot by a woman who was jealously in love with him)

Helentina Kohler 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ

Lathan Kohler 1884 Boothill, Tombstone AZ

Ralph Kohler 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ

Douglas Lilly 1881 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (wagon accident driving for the Sycamore Water Co.)

Judge Chas. Lindley Sept. 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ

Stinging Lizard 1880's Boothill, Tombstone AZ (shot by Cherokee Hall)

M. Lopez 1880 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (Charcoal fumes in a closed room)

Holo Lucero 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (killed by Indians)

Patrick J. Lynch 1883 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (Tombstone saloon keeper located at 309 Allen St)

Bobby Jackson 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (shot with Hart and Serroux over mining claim)

James K. Johnson "Jim" May 1881 aka Henry Johnson and George Johnson.Boothill Graveyard, accidentally shot himself at Galeyville, died of his wounds a few days later. Miner and resident of Charleston.

Six Shooter Jim 1885 Boothill, Tombstone Az (shot by Burt Alvord real name unknown)

John Mackenzie 1881 Boothill, Tombstone AZ

Jos. Manada 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ

Margarita 1880's Boothill, Tombstone (dance hall girl, real name unknown, stabbed by another girl)

John Martin 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (killed working on Huachuca water line, naïve of England)

M. McAllister 1882 Boothill, Tombstone, AZ (sustained a lung injury when shot during a fight over a piece of
land. Went to Tombstone to recover, but died of the injury. Aka Happy Jack

M. McCarthy 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (shot by a man named Poplin, miner)

J.D. McDermott 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (horse accident fractured his spinal column)

Frank McLaury Oct. 26, 1881 Boothill, Tombstone Arizona (murdered behind the OK Corral)

Tom McLaury Oct. 26, 1881 Boothill, Tombstone Arizona (murdered behind the OK Corral)

James McMartin 1881 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (rapid consumption)

McNemony 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (shot, full name unknown)

H. B. Mead 1881 Boothill, Tombstone ( 42 year old blacksmith found dead in rear seat of a coach)

Thos. Morgan 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ

Lester Moore 1880's Boothill, Tombstone AZ (gunfight over a package, both men died. Wells Fargo agent in Naco) Famous epitaph read: "Here lies Lester Moore, four slugs from a 44, no Les no more.

Ben Olleney 1881 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (shot by Chacon)

Daniel Owyer 1881 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (drowned)

Alfred Packrel 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (inflammation of the bowels, 24 year old English miner)

Pesquira 1881 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (full name unknown)

Martin Ruter Peel Mar. 25, 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (mining engineer shot at work. Zwing Hunt & Billy Grounds were both suspects of the murder.

Jim Riley 1881 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (murdered)

G. Renacco 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (fell from a cliff)

Guadalupe Robles 1880's Boothill, Tombstone AZ (shot by officers trying to arrest robbers who were seeking shelter in his house, one of which was his brother)

Rook 1880's Boothill, Tombstone (shot on Fremont Street by a Chinese man, full name unknown)

Rosenthal 1881 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (full name unknown)

C.O. Ridgeway 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (found dead in a wagon along side the road)

Comer W. "Red" Sample Mar. 8, 1884 Boothill, Tombstone - legally hanged

Ben Scott 1883 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (Teamsters Scott & Al Bennett were ambushed by Indians)

Frank Serroux 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (shot with Jackson and Hart over a mining claim)

Mrs. H.C. Smith 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ

Peter Smith 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ - killed by Thos.Doland during a fight

Francis Southy 1881 Boothill, Tombstone AZ

Charlie Storms Feb. 25, 1881 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (shot in a gunfight in front of the Oriental Saloon by Luke Short

Mrs. Stump 1884 Boothill, Tombstone, AZ (overdose of chloroform by doctor during child birth)

Jerry Sullivan 1881 Boothill, Tombstone AZ

Wm. Summers 1882 Boothill, Tombstone, AZ (found dead with a blow on his back that ruptured his liver)

Miles Sweeney 1880 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (murdered)

Jos. Thomas 1881 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (allegedly shot by Indian Joe, a fellow teamster wagon driver)

Dick Toby 1880's Boothill, Tombstone AZ (shot by Sheriff John Behan)

Red River Tom 1880's Boothill, Tombstone AZ (real name unknown, Shot and killed by Ormsby)

James Tulley 1881 Boothill, Tombstone, AZ (fell 250 feet to the bottom of a mine shaft, miner,Grand Central Mining Co.

Tom J. Waters July 1880 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (shot to death by his prospecting friend and cabinmate Edward Lyter Bradshaw after an argument over a blue and black checked shirt, Bradshaw was acquitted in Sept.1880)

Eva Waters 1880's Boothill, Tombstone AZ (3 months old)

Jos. Wetsell 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (stoned to death by Apache Indians)

John Wickstrum 1882 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (crushed and suffocated while digging a well. Swede

Glenn Will 1953 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (his son sent Glenn's Ashes COD $1.92 to the city of Tombstone, to be buried in Boothill.

Delia William 1881 Boothill, Tombstone, AZ (suicide by taking arsenic, colored lodging house proprietress)

Johnnie Wilson 1880's Boothill, Tombstone AZ (shot by King)

George Whitcer 1882 Boothill, Tombstone, AZ (cable snapped sending his miners cage down a shaft)

Marshal Fred White Oct. 28 1880 (32) Boothill, Tombstone (accidentally killed by Curly Bill Brocius on Sixth Street)

William Whitehill 1878 Boothill, Tombstone AZ (shot)

Jasper Von 1882 Boothill, Tombstone - (shot)

Joseph Ziegler 1882 Boothill, Tombstone, AZ (shot through the left breast by fellow miner Ed Williams behind the old ice house near the corner of Toughnut and Fifth Streets.

 

 

 

Back to Haunted Arizona

Back to SGHA Home