Investigation Report

Location: Big Nose Kate's Saloon, Tombstone, Arizona
Date: 12 March 2005
Personnel Participating: teams 1 & 2, Cody & Bob
Weather Conditions: Partly Cloudy
Humidity: 65%
Geomagnetic Storm Activity: Inactive
Temperature: 62
Number of Photos taken: 43
Number with possible targets: 1
Average EM Readings: 4 nt
Average M fields Readings: 1 nt
Average E Field Readings: 1 vpm
Cold Spots detected: None
Hot Spots Detected: None
Olfactory Phenomena: None
Visual Phenomena: None
Type of Investigation: Ghost Hunt

All original information and photos Copyright 2005 by Cody Polston, Bob Carter and SGHA. All Rights Reserved.

Location Description and History

If you look carefully, you can see the seven arches that were part of the Grand Hotel

Many years ago in the late 1800's, Big Nose Kates Saloon was once the Grand Hotel. This great hotel hosted such infamous personalities as Wyatt and Virgil Earp, Doc Holliday, as well as the Clantons, and McLaurys.

And as legend and folk lore have it... in this hotel was a janitor and odd job man, known simply as "The Swamper". He was a trusted and honest helper who was given his accommodations as part of his hard earned pay.

"The Swamper" had his own special bedroom which was located in the dark basement of the Grand Hotel. This was his own special and private place where he could enjoy peace and solitude away from the hustle and bustle of the hotel's many guests. Within his private domain where no guests were invited, he also kept secret his passion for silver.

The basement was deep enough below the surface of the ground to afford entrance into one of the catacombing mine shafts which ran underground beneath the hotel as well as most of Tombstone.

"The Swamper" spent many painstaking hours over a period of years tunneling an entrance into the shaft.

When the digging was completed, he could gain access to a thick vein of silver where he extracted ounce by ounce of the glorious silver nuggets. This mine entrance is still a prominent feature of the bar's basement. Today the shaft that the Swamper dug into the mine is covered with boards and protected by an iron bar gate.

The Grand Hotel (right) in the late 1800's.

It is still unknown if "The Swamper" spent his silver or if he hoarded it in an unknown niche somewhere on the premises of the Grand Hotel. However, several workers of the now "Big Nose Kates saloon" will swear that they have seen a ghost wandering the halls and stairs. It has been reasoned that the ghost is indeed "The Swamper" and that his afterlife is being spent protecting the silver that may still perhaps be buried somewhere in this legendary building.

The seven arches on the outside are all that remain of the Grand Hotel above ground. The floor joists of the building are original having survived the fire. When the building was being renovated, digging had to be done in the basement area to make room for a spiral staircase to allow access for the customers. Artifacts, mostly old bottles and tin, were discovered as the excavation occurred.

According to local legend, the charred remains of the Grand Hotel collapsed into its basement, leaving only a small section of it accessible. If people died in the fire, their remains may still be hidden

in the unexcavated section of the saloon's basement. Originally, the bar area was down stairs in the basement, while the upper levels were strictly the hotel. One of the many Tombstone mining shafts still leads into the basement bar area, that has just been opened back up to customers after 100 years! This really made it easy for the thirsty miners in the 1880's. They would simply come up through the shaft into the basement bar area, have a drink, then head on back to their jobs as hard rock miners.

From the Tombstone Epitaph, ( September 9, 1880)
THE GRAND HOTEL

Through the courtesy of Mr. H.V. Sturm an Epitaph reporter yesterday paid a visit to and made a brief inspection of the new hotel christened the grand which will be formally open for dinner this evening at five o'clock. The general size and character of the structure have been mentioned so often during the course of construction that further mention would be superfluous and we will confine ourselves to a description of the interior appointments of it. Passing into the building by the front entrance the first thing that strikes the eye is a wide and handsome staircase covered by an elegant carpet and supporting a heavy black walnut banister. Thence upstairs to the main hall, and turning to the right we are ushered into a perfect little bijou of costly furniture and elegant carpeting known as the bridal chamber. This room occupies half of the main front and is connected with the parlor by folding doors through which the reporter passed, and entering the parlor was more than astonished by the luxurious appointments. A heavy brussels carpet of the most elegant style and finish graces the floor, the walls are adorned with rare and costly oil paintings; the furniture is of walnut cushioned with the most expensive silk and rep, and nothing lacks, save the piano which will be placed in the position shortly. On down through the main corridor peeping now and then into the bedrooms, sixteen in number, each of them fitted with walnut furniture and carpeted to match: spring mattresses that would tempt even a sybarite, toilet stands and fixtures of the most approved pattern, the walls papered, and to crown all, each room having windows. All are outside rooms thus obviating the many comforts in close and ill-ventilated apartments. Returning we pass down the broad staircase and turning to the left are in the office and reading room. Here we met Mr. R.J. Pryke, the polite and affable clerk, so well known to Yosemite tourists in California. The office fixtures are as is common in first class hotels and fully in keeping with the general character of the house. The dining room adjoining next invites inspection. Here we find the same evidence of good taste in selection and arrangement that is so marked a feature of the whole interior. Three elegant chandeliers are pendant from the handsome centerpieces, walnut tables, extension and plain, covered with cut glass, china, silver castors and the latest style of cutlery are among the many attractions of this branch of the cuisine.

Thence into the kitchen where we find the same evidence before mentioned; an elegant Montagin range 12 feet in length, with patent heater, hot and cold faucets, in fact all the appliances necessary to feed five hundred persons at a few hours notice are present. The bar occupies the east half of the main front and is in keeping with the general furnishings. Want of space prevents more than this cursory glance at the Grand and its appliances for the comfort and convenience of guests. A Grand (no pun intended) invitation ball will take place this evening.

Reported Phenomena

Several workers of the Saloon will swear that they have seen a ghost wandering the halls and stairs.

Photographers have caught the ghostly image of an unknown being on a photo as well as on the postcard of the saloon's interior. One of the most famous was taken by James Kidd (top left photo) who was a local photographer in Tombstone. Other photographs taken of the same section of the saloon's bar contain unusual images as well (below left). Sometimes, pictures taken of the section do not even turn out or the camera malfunctions.

It has been reasoned that the ghost is indeed "The Swamper" and that his afterlife is being spent protecting the silver that may still perhaps be buried somewhere in this legendary building.

The ghosts of cowboys have been seen standing in doorways, seated at the bar and knocking over cases of beer in the basement. Other occurrences are that things fall from the ceiling and roll across the floor. Doors will open and close by themselves, lights will turn on and off and silverware will fly off the table as customers are sitting down to a meal.

One of the more unusual occurrences happened to the owner of the building and several of his employees one evening. It was "off-season" and business was slow so they all decided to open the entrance to the mine shaft and explore it. While they did discover that the "Swampers" shaft did indeed connect into the Toughnut Mine, the ghost apparently did not like them entering his tunnel. As they were coming out of the shaft, a loud screaming moaning sound came thundering down the back staircase accompanied by the sound of heavy footsteps moving down the stairs towards them.

Quickly, one of the employees scattered out of the mine shaft and moved towards the stairs, thinking that someone had managed to get inside the building. However, the owner had locked the door before the excursion began and when the employee reached the stairs he discovered that no one was there. A quick check of the doors confirmed that they were still locked.

The back staircase leading into the basement

The back staircase leading to the basement has been the scene of other unusual events. Whenever female employees walked down these stairs alone, something very frightening would happen. As they stepped onto the second to the last step, an unseen force would violently push them off the stairs. This phenomena would only occur to women and oddly enough, it has not occurred since the steps were replaced many years ago.

Another active area of the basement is the end opposite of the back stairs. This was the original location of the staircase that descended into the basement from the lobby of the Grand Hotel. Today a storage area conceals this area.

A former manager was sitting in this area with a group of friends when they decided to turn out the lights to see if the ghost would show up. As they all sat there in the dark, she felt an uneasy presence that seemed to approach the group from the mine shaft. Then she felt what she described as "cold, clammy hands", clamped around her throat, as if the presence was trying to strangle her.

Fortunately, one of her friends decided to turn on a flashlight and saw her choking. The group quickly turned on the light and the presence went away.

On the ground floor of the saloon, the mannequins in the false balcony have been seen to move and on several occasions, they have been tossed down from their location.

Footsteps of an unknown origin are also commonly heard on the ground floor after closing, when all is quiet. The phenomena is often noticed near the rear of the bar.

 

The Investigation

We arrived on location at midnight, just after the saloon closed for the evening. The teams searched the ground floor of the saloon while Cody, Bob and Dave were accompanied to the basement by the owner. The Team on the ground floor conducted interviews while the Team in the basement talked with the owner about the reported sightings, events and the building's history.

After the interviews were completed, both groups searched the location for unusual electromagnetic fields. The most interesting field that was found was in the basement, near the Swampers lair. Fluctuations of up to 7 nt were recorded on the Trifield meter whenever Bob mentioned anything about "stealing" the Swamper's silver. During this time, Cody moved up the back staircase and took EVP samples.

The Teams met back up on the ground floor and discussed their findings. A more in depth look at the saloon could be quite beneficial.

     

Electronic Voice Phenomena (EVP)

Question
Answer
Frequency
Listen
Where did you hide your silver so we can get it back to you?
Sounds like "anonymous graveyard"
206.13 HZ
Why are you here?
Sounds like "Greed, it devours"
213.06 HZ

 

Initial Conclusions

Photographic Analysis

There is one interesting photograph that was taken at the saloon during our visit. The photographs has an unusual anomaly in it near Bob's head. It has a "ecto" like structure to it, but it is not like a mist or cloud-ish structure that is normally associated with that type of phenomena.

It more closely resembles a chemical spot that was splashed on the negative during the developing process. The problem is that this is a digital image, thus no negative. Another interesting fact is that the photographs taken before and after this image are completely normal. No smoke or dust particles are present in them and nothing resembling this "ecto's" shape can be found in the preceding photos.

The "orb" near Dave's elbow is more than likely a dust particle because diffraction rings can be seen in its structure.

Back to Haunted Arizona

Back to SGHA Home